Tuesday 7 August 2012

DEBATE OF FUZZAL BIN HASAN WITH ABU HANIFA ABOUT ABUBAKR


Once Fazaal bin Hassan (Companion of Imam Jaffar e Sadiq as ) was walking through the streets of kufa with his friend.
He saw that Imam Abu Hanifa was surrounded of some people and those people were asking some religious questions from him.
Fazaal Bin Hassan said to his friend:
‘Today i will not let him (Abu Hanifa) go without unveiling him.’
Friend of fazaal Bin Hassan said:
‘But he is very intelligent man in religious point of view.’
Fazaal Bin hassan Said:
‘Now you will u see how intelligent he is .’
And then Fazaal bin Hassan approached to Abu Hanifa said to him:
“O! Abu Hanifa, there is my brother who use to say that after Rasoolullah, Hazrat  Ali  is best among the people. But I say that there is Abu Bakr and then Umar”
What do you say in this regard?
Imam Abu Hanifa thought for some moments and then replied:
“For the superiority of these two (Abu Bakr and Umar) this is sufficient that they got burial sites next to Rasoolullah. Don’t you know?”
Fazaal Bin Hassan said:
‘Yes I know , when I said this point to my brother he said:
“Either, the place where they (Abu Bakr and Umar) are buried was the property of Rasoolullah . Hence, it not legal for anyone to bury someone on that place without the permission.”
Or.
“It was property Of Abu Bakr and Umar they gave it to Rasoolullah. So again it is illegal for them to interfere in the gift which they gave to Rasoolullah.”
Abu Hanifa again thought for some moments and then replied:
It was property of Rasoolullah. But both Abu Bakr and Umar are buried in the shares of their daughters (Ayesha and  Hafsa) . Because that place was the property of Wives of Rasoolullah after his Wisal (death). This is why Abu bakr and Umar are buried there.
Fazaal bin Hassan Said:
Yes I know I also told him that thing but my brother said :
Rasoolullah left nine wives after his death. So every wife had equal right over that place.
AND SECONDLY IF THE WIVES OF RASOOLULLAH CAN INHERIT THAT PLACE FROM HIM,
THEN WHY ABU BAKR REFUSED TO GIVE FADAK TO JANABE SAYYIDA AND SAID THAT PROPERTY LEFT BY PROPHETS GOES IN CHARITY?
After listening this Abu Hanifa said to his men.
Kick him out of here he is Shia.
( EHTIJAJ TABARSI pg: 207)

No comments:

Post a Comment